5 Unexpected Pedicure Shades I Keep Seeing on the Toes of Brooklyn’s It Girls
Our take

The resurgence of considered detail, even in seemingly minor aspects of personal style, speaks volumes about the current cultural moment. It’s no longer enough to simply *have* beautiful things; we’re seeking intentionality, a quiet confidence that radiates from the smallest choices. This article highlighting unexpected pedicure shades seen on the toes of Brooklyn’s “it girls” is a perfect microcosm of that shift. It’s not about a loud, trend-driven statement, but about a subtle elevation of the everyday—a considered choice that elevates a simple sandal or bare foot. Following the long, isolating winter, and as we collectively rediscover the joy of warm-weather dressing, this focus on meticulously curated details feels incredibly resonant. The desire to refine and polish, to feel put-together even in effortless moments, is a powerful current. It aligns perfectly with the broader trend of embracing elevated basics [If You Want to Look Elegant This Summer, Consider These 9 Elevated Basics]—a move away from fleeting trends and towards enduring style.
What’s particularly compelling about this trend isn’t just the colors themselves (the article mentions shades like sage green and dusty rose), but the underlying philosophy. It reflects a move away from the predictable, the universally accepted “summer pedicure” colors, towards something more nuanced and personal. It’s about showcasing individuality within a framework of understated luxury, a sensibility that resonates deeply with the modern muse. We see a similar inclination towards personal expression within the broader fashion landscape, as demonstrated by the recent renewed interest in summer fashion following a period of stagnation [I Thought I Was Bored of Summer Fashion—Then I Saw These 19 Nordstrom Anniversary Sale Pieces]. The desire for a fresh perspective, a way to inject personality into familiar silhouettes, is driving these choices. The shift also echoes the broader aesthetic movement towards “Mediterranean Nails,” an embrace of sun-drenched hues and natural beauty [Pause the Neutral Manis—Mediterranean Nails Are All I Want on My Hands This Summer]. This suggests a deeper yearning for connection with nature, a desire to translate the effortless beauty of the Mediterranean landscape into a tangible form.
The beauty here lies in the subtlety. These aren't neon, attention-grabbing shades designed to shout from the rooftops. They're quiet, sophisticated, and inherently chic. They’re the kind of detail that someone with a discerning eye will notice and appreciate – a silent signal of considered taste and effortless style. It’s a move that aligns perfectly with the principles of quiet luxury, where quality and craftsmanship speak louder than ostentation. The focus isn’t on the price tag or the brand name; it’s on the inherent beauty of the detail and the feeling it evokes. This approach to beauty—a focus on mood, atmosphere, and feeling—is far more enduring than chasing fleeting trends. It's about creating a personal aesthetic that feels authentic and deeply connected to one’s own sense of self.
Ultimately, the rise of these unexpected pedicure shades speaks to a broader cultural shift: a move away from performative beauty and towards a more introspective and intentional approach to personal style. It's a reflection of a desire to cultivate a sense of inner confidence and project it outwards through subtle, considered choices. As we move forward, it will be fascinating to see how this emphasis on micro-details continues to evolve and influence other aspects of personal style. Will we see this level of intentionality applied to other seemingly minor elements—the choice of earring, the way a scarf is tied, the texture of a handbag? Or will this be a fleeting trend, a momentary fascination with the power of a perfectly executed pedicure?
All it takes is one morning stroll down the streets of New York to understand that I’m definitely not the only person who missed the sandals section of her closet. The winter was brutal (I have the lingering eczema marks on my cheeks to prove it), which meant that I—and everyone else in the northern hemisphere—welcomed summer’s arrival with eager open arms, and plenty of open-toed footwear. Whether you land on the Birkenstock side of the sandal spectrum or wouldn’t be caught dead in less than a four-inch heel, the fact remains that the feet, and the toes, are out to play, and that means summer pedicures are an absolute must.
Sure, the bare nails trend continues to reign supreme for your fingertips, but frankly, I feel a little exposed when my toenails are totally sans polish. Even if I’m feeling particularly minimalist, I’ll hit them with a quick swipe of clear or jelly polish before walking out the door. Since I also know that treating myself to a pedicure is one of those rare moments of total relaxation—for at least 30 minutes—I’ve been scouting for the shades the most stylish women in the city are wearing this season. Keep scrolling for the five hottest summer pedicure trends.
Bright Whites, Big City
It took me a while to embrace the white nail polish look, but now that milky polish is everywhere, I finally feel like I’m ready to join the (very chic) club.

My go-to brand for clean lacquer that actually nourishes my nails. I adore this slightly pearlescent white for an impossibly chic pedi.

The GOAT of all milky white nail polishes, I’m never without this classic formula in my at-home nail kit.
Flaunt It French
Whoever said that French tips on the toes are passé hasn’t spent enough time strolling through Brooklyn. Every enviably dressed woman had the classic design peeking through her mesh flats.

Yes, press-ons for your toes exist, and they are the greatest hack for a flawless French pedicure in a flash. This kit has everything you need, with easy application tabs, to create the look without a salon appointment.

A pinky rich nude that lasts and lasts, I always turn to this classic color for my French tip nails.
Moody Mauve
Mauve nails had a major moment this spring, and I’m happy to see that the cool-girl shade has stuck around for the summer.

A mauve-meets-brown shade that’s just begging to be worn with a pair of minimalist flip flops.

The perfect deep, dusty mauve—I can see myself wearing this all the way through summer and into fall—when, yes, I still make sure to keep my toes pedicured, even when they’re buried beneath cashmere socks.
Pretty In Pink
Think that pink isn’t for you? Try a chrome finish for an unexpected twist on the sweet shade.

There’s no need to book a gel appointment for chrome nails when you have this gorgeous Barbie pink polish in your collection.

This pink holographic polish is practically its own accessory. I just need the perfect pair of black kitten heels to wear with it and I’m set for the summer.
Dare to Bare
Like I said, bare nails are everywhere right now, but I, and many of my beauty editor friends, have taken to swiping on a clear or barely-there polish to elevate the look.

Like a pH lip balm but for your nails, this nourishing formula provides that barely-there pink with one coat, and builds up to a jelly-like pink with a second and third layer. It’s sublime.

A three-in-one polish that helps to strengthen your nails, prevent chipping, and deliver a deliciously glossy finish.
Why Trust Marie Claire
For more than 30 years, Marie Claire has been an internationally recognized destination for news, fashion, and beauty trends, investigative packages, and more. When it comes to the products Marie Claire recommends, we take your faith in us seriously. Every product that we feature comes personally recommended by a Marie Claire writer or editor, or by an expert we’ve spoken to firsthand.
Don't gatekeep our newsletters from your friends. Subscribe to Face Forward here.
Read on the original site
Open the publisher's page for the full experience