Can anyone help me narrow down what is causing a reaction?

Over the past two or so years, I’ve developed a weird reaction to some products I put on my lips. I can’t narrow down similar ingredients that would be causing it. My lips will burn, turn red and blister a bit, right along the border of my lips especially. Then over the next few days, they’ll peel and burn.

Ones that DO cause a reaction:

• Summer Fridays lip butter (specifically the vanilla beige)

• Aquaphor

• Jeffree Star liquid lips

Ones that DON’T cause a reaction:

• Old Henriksen Pout Peptide Lip Treatment (I have several colours and they all seem to be fine)

• Vaseline

• Mac Lipstick and Lip liners

I’m stumped!